Table 1: ACG Relative Expenditure Data for Physician Services

ACG relative expenditure data for physician services provided to the Manitoba population and data from a parallel study in British Columbia (Reid, Weiner, Starfield et al. 1998). In the BC study, ACG resource intensity weights were developed for a 5% stratified random sample of BC residents (n=171,157) who were continuously enrolled in the province’s health plan in 1995-96. In contrast to physician expenditure data in Manitoba, the expenditures in BC excluded payments for laboratory and radiology services. The table also includes expenditure data for physician plus hospital services to Manitobans and to patients in two USA locations. There is also data for physician plus hospital plus pharmaceutical expenditures in Manitoba.

Mean Costs & Relative Cost Wgts (OUTLIERS were TRIMMED) per ACG.
All Manitoba 95/96
All Physician Costs:
Physician+Hosp. Costs:
MD+Hosp+Drug
Costs (1997/98):
MB
MB 
MB 
B.C. 
MB
MB
Minesota
USA
MB
MB
ACG
N
Mean
Relative
Relative
Mean
Medicaid
HMO
Mean
Relative
Cost
Cost Wgt
Cost Wgt
Cost
 Relativ Cost Wgt
Cost
Cost Wgt
100
2210
$96.21
0.40
0.41
$111.15
0.14
0.36
0.10
$117.66
0.12
200
13172
66.41
0.27
0.34
70.98
0.09
0.29
0.06
86.54
0.08
300
127612
56.95
0.23
0.27
61.84
0.08
0.29
0.11
97.42
0.10
400
34351
88.43
0.35
0.27
173.36
0.21
0.58
0.28
194.76
0.19
500
44101
66.20
0.26
0.21
88.62
0.11
0.31
0.14
131.69
0.13
600
2620
76.75
0.30
0.25
86.04
0.11
0.24
0.16
141.11
0.14
700
3490
53.36
0.22
0.25
62.84
0.08
0.24
0.11
194.75
0.19
800
6592
152.60
0.59
0.49
747.60
0.91
0.93
0.28
1122.07
1.10
900
23983
91.60
0.37
0.34
96.01
0.12
0.47
0.10
357.70
0.35
1000
1086
58.71
0.22
0.20
67.07
0.08
0.24
0.09
126.78
0.12
1100
8308
69.45
0.25
0.19
93.28
0.11
0.24
0.08
224.09
0.22
1200
3107
75.33
0.29
0.26
94.07
0.12
0.33
0.22
185.26
0.18
1300
7686
155.28
0.54
0.59
161.19
0.20
1.40
0.13
286.90
0.28
1400
1250
254.52
0.97
0.67
1320.90
1.62
2.83
0.17
1598.80
1.57
1500
528
589.98
2.33
2.14
2335.72
2.86
3.87
0.12
2482.27
2.44
1600
26898
53.01
0.22
0.14
54.42
0.07
0.22
0.05
97.35
0.10
1710
1779
129.64
0.54
0.18
1365.78
1.67
0.56
2.53
1396.42
1.37
1711
1352
137.08
0.57
n/a
1756.27
2.15
n/a
n/a
1788.46
1.76
1712
427
107.22
0.44
n/a
129.37
0.16
n/a
n/a
166.15
0.16
1720
7004
207.16
0.86
0.87
1471.29
1.80
1.08
2.86
1462.89
1.44
1721
4967
215.27
0.90
n/a
1967.22
2.41
n/a
n/a
2017.21
1.98
1722
2037
187.41
0.78
n/a
262.01
0.32
n/a
n/a
343.73
0.34
1730
1079
224.75
0.92
0.89
2108.16
2.58
1.24
3.97
2264.61
2.22
1731
890
222.96
0.91
n/a
2391.29
2.92
n/a
n/a
2532.75
2.49
1732
189
233.03
0.95
n/a
774.89
0.95
n/a
n/a
1147.32
1.13
1740
5071
301.21
1.25
1.58
1598.03
1.95
1.61
3.62
1587.04
1.56
1741
3153
313.65
1.31
n/a
2283.37
2.79
n/a
n/a
2342.85
2.30
1742
1918
280.59
1.16
n/a
471.40
0.58
n/a
n/a
578.93
0.57
1750
2194
351.45
1.44
1.72
2417.52
2.96
1.92
4.42
2436.94
2.39
1751
1587
349.56
1.44
n/a
2907.03
3.56
n/a
n/a
2971.39
2.92
1752
607
356.40
1.45
n/a
1137.68
1.39
n/a
n/a
1300.59
1.28
1760
2754
442.17
1.84
2.69
1772.71
2.17
2.75
4.62
1888.12
1.85
1761
1460
456.88
1.90
n/a
2688.74
3.29
n/a
n/a
2811.65
2.76
1762
1294
425.57
1.76
n/a
739.16
0.90
n/a
n/a
976.56
0.96
1770
3261
621.21
2.52
3.76
3062.91
3.75
4.69
6.86
3095.87
3.04
1771
1922
604.37
2.48
n/a
3930.63
4.81
n/a
n/a
4033.06
3.96
1772
1339
645.37
2.57
n/a
1817.38
2.22
n/a
n/a
2016.33
1.98
1800
52825
150.33
0.60
0.72
270.05
0.33
0.84
0.53
299.74
0.29
1900
5337
195.12
0.80
0.83
244.67
0.30
0.71
0.23
268.89
0.26
2000
15574
142.50
0.59
0.68
166.23
0.20
0.53
0.18
201.21
0.20
2100
61059
125.94
0.51
0.56
165.77
0.20
0.52
0.31
235.75
0.23
2200
5238
149.85
0.61
0.68
173.82
0.21
0.56
0.39
252.62
0.25
2300
22153
145.65
0.60
0.63
163.61
0.20
0.51
0.21
427.82
0.42
2400
6968
120.13
0.47
0.48
156.49
0.19
0.47
0.21
277.22
0.27
2500
9476
189.65
0.71
0.94
210.41
0.26
1.48
0.23
326.79
0.32
2600
814
270.60
1.02
1.25
948.65
1.16
3.05
0.23
1644.18
1.61
2700
523
651.93
2.58
3.04
1833.56
2.24
5.08
2.30
2134.79
2.10
2800
16758
179.29
0.72
0.54
355.85
0.44
0.84
0.70
431.21
0.42
2900
3146
300.95
1.24
1.36
653.52
0.80
1.66
0.86
638.24
0.63
3000
7257
228.09
0.94
1.13
349.19
0.43
1.28
0.57
387.55
0.38
3100
5887
205.45
0.84
1.00
319.20
0.39
1.11
0.81
342.88
0.34
3200
33482
267.53
1.09
1.20
494.38
0.60
1.37
1.13
587.92
0.58
3300
2663
276.85
1.13
1.38
394.23
0.48
1.25
1.38
533.69
0.52
3400
4631
195.59
0.79
0.78
269.38
0.33
0.74
0.40
453.34
0.45
3500
8595
312.06
1.19
1.34
456.89
0.56
1.79
0.46
606.69
0.60
3600
16513
443.83
1.83
1.78
1012.95
1.24
2.55
2.01
1303.31
1.28
3700
9963
478.77
1.90
2.33
1008.38
1.23
3.04
1.24
1187.63
1.17
3800
15231
145.57
0.58
0.63
249.12
0.30
1.34
0.33
312.61
0.31
3900
9933
186.59
0.71
0.68
372.81
0.46
2.17
0.53
489.73
0.48
4000
10394
194.67
0.76
0.70
300.12
0.37
0.85
0.46
428.52
0.42
4100
85949
244.55
0.97
0.79
626.92
0.77
1.03
0.60
961.40
0.94
4210
8901
248.00
1.01
1.14
440.14
0.54
1.94
0.68
501.87
0.49
4220
3068
329.98
1.31
1.22
814.01
1.00
2.75
1.24
908.33
0.89
4310
16261
289.78
1.15
1.19
400.02
0.49
1.15
0.83
614.75
0.60
4320
10831
382.91
1.52
1.38
792.08
0.97
1.83
1.54
1030.65
1.01
4330
2616
600.87
2.41
1.57
2270.81
2.78
3.83
2.99
2632.75
2.58
4410
22564
343.73
1.40
1.26
524.81
0.64
0.87
0.81
963.80
0.95
4420
25922
453.70
1.85
1.53
1289.77
1.58
2.13
1.84
1849.35
1.82
4430
11627
704.00
2.84
2.14
5299.61
6.48
2.75
4.60
6120.09
6.01
4510
1509
431.77
1.79
2.14
1103.53
1.35
2.81
1.53
1143.64
1.12
4520
773
667.21
2.69
2.42
3450.67
4.22
5.47
3.28
3855.42
3.79
4610
1553
413.51
1.63
1.89
711.37
0.87
2.50
1.34
861.85
0.85
4620
989
657.96
2.62
2.35
2394.22
2.93
6.50
4.01
3014.13
2.96
4710
701
416.10
1.68
2.29
604.09
0.74
3.56
2.07
830.06
0.81
4720
1298
549.28
2.21
2.52
1053.90
1.29
5.03
2.06
1349.54
1.33
4730
957
931.00
3.73
2.71
5175.56
6.33
10.05
6.18
4926.09
4.84
4810
2988
454.73
1.83
2.16
662.24
0.81
2.19
1.61
921.29
0.90
4820
2612
561.22
2.27
2.49
1101.85
1.35
2.95
2.44
1366.23
1.34
4830
980
912.76
3.67
3.28
3615.65
4.42
5.52
5.45
3635.00
3.57
4910
32920
623.43
2.56
2.38
1464.37
1.79
2.69
2.50
2132.46
2.09
4920
14571
920.58
3.78
3.20
5185.40
6.34
5.27
5.78
5671.66
5.57
4930
6288
1332.95
5.50
4.35
11307.51
13.83
9.83
12.17
12014.22
11.80
4940
2126
1954.50
8.21
6.09
20958.96
25.63
14.64
20.35
21670.37
21.28
5010
78
1021.75
4.04
3.91
3978.53
4.87
5.24
6.20
3981.90
3.91
5020
90
1137.66
4.74
4.26
6873.31
8.41
13.25
5.27
9406.58
9.24
5030
82
2796.90
11.56
5.51
33702.52
41.22
44.55
22.87
22476.30
22.07
5040
2864
1002.62
4.11
4.33
2193.26
2.68
5.11
3.97
3194.02
3.14
5050
3034
1314.06
5.43
5.11
5468.23
6.69
8.00
6.46
6299.46
6.18
5060
2387
1741.55
7.19
6.34
12199.92
14.92
16.66
13.63
12440.73
12.21
5070
2312
2594.62
10.84
8.32
24122.13
29.50
47.09
27.83
24569.17
24.12
5110
86
129.38
0.51
0.19
256.87
0.31
0.18
0.14
349.91
0.34
5200
198657
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
5310
12384
174.60
0.72
1.05
738.29
0.90
1.64
2.78
753.98
0.74
5311
261
215.32
0.86
n/a
1724.81
2.11
n/a
n/a
1510.94
1.48
5312
12123
173.76
0.72
n/a
717.05
0.88
n/a
n/a
729.77
0.72
5320
1647
289.06
1.16
1.22
2148.43
2.63
2.33
12.35
2331.48
2.29
5321
244
365.64
1.49
n/a
5232.81
6.40
n/a
n/a
5641.46
5.54
5322
1403
276.12
1.10
n/a
1612.02
1.97
n/a
n/a
1687.95
1.66
5330
738
446.92
1.83
2.40
1756.32
2.15
3.52
3.42
1802.92
1.77
5331
21
460.10
1.93
n/a
2721.43
3.33
n/a
n/a
3658.81
3.59
5332
717
446.53
1.82
n/a
1728.05
2.11
n/a
n/a
1722.76
1.69
5340
726
759.09
3.04
3.82
6653.57
8.14
8.93
14.79
6436.92
6.32
5341
143
986.87
3.97
n/a
11994.90
14.67
n/a
n/a
11020.39
10.82
5342
583
703.22
2.81
n/a
5343.43
6.54
n/a
n/a
5521.73
5.42
©2003 Manitoba Centre for Health Policy (MCHP)